Who are Appellate Attorneys and why is it necessary to prefer them for an Appeal?

Whenever there is a complex case or a tricky trial nobody would take a chance to fight it without hiring a defense attorney with courtroom experience so the rights will be legally and wholly protected. The same goes for difficult and complex appeals. When someone gets a verdict from a lower court that is unacceptable or the defendant wants a further hearing, then hiring an appellate attorney would become a necessity.

Who are appellate attorneys and what do they do, keep reading to further dig into it.

Who are appellate attorneys?

Appellate attorneys fight cases from the lower courts such as criminal and civil courts and raise appeals to higher courts like the Supreme Court or Court of Appeal for a further hearing or to analyze further evidence that was not handled carefully before the verdict.

Appeals are considered in both federal and state courts. State courts are further divided into two courts of appeals, a district court of appeal and a State Supreme Court. On the other hand, a federal appellate court is further divided into a United States District Court of Appeal, a District Court (hears trial court cases), and the United States Supreme Court.

Appellate attorneys usually are committed to taking cases from trial courts that deal with both civil and criminal cases and submit appeals to higher courts to review or reverse a decision, challenge a verdict, reverse a legal error made in front of the trial judge, review a decision on a motion to suppress a criminal case.

When a losing party raises the appeals against a case to a Supreme Court or a higher court, the party would be referred to as Appellant or Petitioner. On the contrary, when a winning party appeals before a higher court, the party is called Respondent or Appellee.

Either way an appellant or appellant, an appellate attorney is obligated to file a brief to debate on the merit of law as it lies under the basic laws to be presented in front of the trial court jury or the trial court judge.

What is an Appeal?

Whether an appellee or appellant wants to challenge a decision from a lower court to receive a favorable verdict, then an appeal is the best way to opt. The best thing about an appeal is that it can be made in both civil and criminal cases.

For instance, a criminal appeal occurs when a defendant of a criminal case loses a motion in a pre-trial which may include a motion to suppress evidence, a motion to exclude evidence, or a motion to carry on a trial. In addition to that, criminal appeals can also be made if the defendant receives convictions before a judge in the trial court.

The defendant, in this case, is eligible to plead against the court verdict, conviction, and even the sentence. This is because there are chances of mistakes at the trial court and appeals are made in order to ensure that the rule of law should be followed even at trial courts.

An example of a civil appeal would be defined when a party challenges the court verdict or appeals to overturn a trial court’s decision on the basis of evidence in hand. A trial court may allow the evidence that is excluded at the lower courts. When this happens, the appellant or appellee can appeal in front of the appellate judges for a review decision.

What is a trial court?

A trial court is a place where all the civil cases take place and majority of which are settled. In the trial court, the trial judge reviews the evidence, hears the arguments, and decides whether the evidence against a case is allowed or not. Once both the parties have presented the case, argued on the evidence, presented everything including witnesses, then the trial court jury will decide the verdict and conclude the case.

What is an appellate court?

Once the verdict comes from the trial court, an appellant or the appellant can file an appeal if any evidence or witness was not handled appropriately at the trial court. Unlike appellate court, there isn’t any sitting jury at the appellate court.

To review a case at the appellate court there’s a panel of judges with the legal obligation of viewing trial cases such as court records, testimonies, legal briefs, etc.)

There are some exceptions in order to have evidence reviewed. The lawyers must present any evidence in the trial court to have it reviewed by the appellate court. If evidence, testimony, or any brief was not initially presented in the trial court, the appellate court will not consider it during the appeal. This is why it is important to have evidence presented and make objections (if any) at the trial to have it discussed in appellate court.

However, the panel of judges at the appellate court will decide the final verdict regardless of whether the decision made by the trial court was in accordance with the law.

Is it necessary for a trial court lawyer to object to an appeal?

Most of the time it is a must for a trial attorney to object either during or before trial to preserve the right of appeal. In both civil and criminal cases, objections are important. It is necessary to object to appeal against a verdict to the appeal courts.

Appellate court judges also require an objection when it comes to giving a chance to trial courts to review the decision in the light of the law and make the decision for the issue in question. For instance, a lawyer at the trial court can object when the prosecution counter questions the witness on the leading evidence.

It is also important to note here that if the counter-question influence the results at the trial and a trial attorney raises an objection, the verdict of the trial court to deny or admit the pertaining evidence can be appealed at a higher court and request the high court judges to review the verdict given by the trial court judge.

While there’s always a need for objections in order to review an appellate review, there may be some exceptions attached to it every time.

For instance, the decisions made by lower court judges can be reviewed if there are identifiable legal plain error(s). However, the issues of plain error do not necessarily require an objection to be made in the trial court.

The trial court plain errors are so unfair and sometimes biased that the appellate court can review the case without any objection. Nonetheless, a plain error issue is the safest way to have the appellate review. In order to have the option of criminal or civil appeal, it is important to have the objection properly made in place at the time of trial.

How to become an appellate attorney by specializing in appellate law?

Appeals are the process by which made the American Judicial system impartial and unbiased. Appeals are usually made to review a court decision in order to change or alternate the trial court verdict made after the procedural errors.

Appellate work is trickier in order to get success towards a case that went through trial; a single mistake in evidentiary finding or filing, the minor conflict of interest, or any outside procedure can overturn the verdict.

This translates that the appellate field needs strong attention to detail, trapping memory, and love for research are all that make a good appellate attorney.

Appellate Law FAQs

If filing an appeal is in your consideration in the criminal and civil case. If you are served with the appeal notice from a civil court, then you may have thoughts about how the appeal process works. Here are some basic questions that you should consider understanding;

Filing an appeal depends on the trial court verdict. If an appellee or appellant wants the appellate court to review the trial court verdict then any party can appeal.

Any evidence that was not initially handled by the legal ordinances, ruling, verdict, post and pre-judgment motions can be taken to appeal court to be reviewed by the jury panel.

The first step involved in filing an appeal is to file a ‘notice of appeal’ in a circuit court. Once the notice is served to the plaintiffs or defendant, you need to file a petition in the appellate court.  Furthermore, you have to file and obtain a trial record.

Oftentimes matters are appealable in the trial court by right while many are discretionary. The acceptance of your appeal will be determined depending on the strength of your petition.


Recent Posts